CaraComp
CaraComp
Forensic-Grade AI Face Recognition for:
Get Started7-day refund guarantee**
Podcast

Age Verification: Adult Site Is Back, Apple Holds Age Data

Age Verification: Adult Site Is Back, Apple Holds Age Data

Quick answer

Who should hold your proof of age when a website asks for it?

Ideally the proof stays with as few parties as possible. Device-based checks, like Apple's, tell a site only that you are an adult, with no ID upload or face scan. The risk does not vanish, though. It moves to the company holding the age data, and no current method protects privacy perfectly.

Age Verification: Adult Site Is Back, Apple Holds Age Data

0:00-0:00

This episode is based on our article:

Read the full article →

Age Verification: Adult Site Is Back, Apple Holds Age Data

Full Episode Transcript


Pornhub left Australia in March because it said handing over your ID to prove your age was too risky. Now it's back. Nothing in the law changed. What changed is that Apple stepped in to do the age check instead. If you've ever uploaded a photo of your driver's license to prove who you are, this story is about you. Because the question underneath it is simple. When a website needs to know your age, who should hold that proof? Here are the facts, according to ABC News Australia. New age verification rules took effect in Australia this year. Pornhub's parent company, Aylo, blocked the country in March. Its argument was that collecting personal information for these checks would create serious data privacy risks. Then Apple rolled out age verification built into its devices. Pornhub came back, but only for people using Apple products. So the real story isn't about one website. It's about which kind of age check a company will accept, and which kind it won't. That tells us a lot about where the danger actually sits. Start with how the Apple method works. Apple describes it as one of the strongest and hardest-to-dodge protections available for keeping kids away from adult content. Your phone confirms you're an adult. The site never receives an ID upload or a face scan. It just gets a yes. Compare that to the usual approach. You hand a website your name, your birthday, maybe a picture of your Facial Recognition Attendance West Bengal Scans Kids Faces. Critics say that ties your most sensitive and permanent information to what you do online. And you can change a password. You can't change your face. This isn't a theoretical worry. Adult sites have been breached before. Those leaks showed what happens when someone's identity gets linked to sensitive behavior. Civil society groups warn that new age-verification tools could repeat those failures on a much bigger scale. Now, that explains why Pornhub's parent company pushed back. But notice what it did next. It didn't fight the rules forever. It waited for a method it liked better. The company has long argued that checking age at the device is safer than checking at every single site. Apple gave it a way to say yes. That points to a pattern. Companies tend to pick the least invasive option on the table. Collecting IDs and face scans creates risk for them, too. It means storing data that can leak, and answering for it when it does. For lawmakers, that's a hard lesson. If a gentler technical option exists, forcing the invasive one gets very difficult. There's a catch, though. The return only helps some people. Android users still can't get in. Neither can anyone without a smartphone. One fix for one slice of the market leaves everyone else outside. And a French investigation in twenty twenty-two looked at six common age-check methods. Its finding was blunt. No current solution reliably verifies age, covers the whole population, and protects privacy, all at once. Every option gives something up. That's the part critics keep pressing. Apple now holds age data tied to identity for millions of Australians. The risk didn't disappear. It moved. For an everyday user, that's a trade. You're trusting one big company instead of many small ones.


Trusted by Investigators Worldwide
Run Forensic-Grade Comparisons in Seconds
Detailed facial comparison reports. Results in seconds.
Get Started
7-day refund guarantee**

The Bottom Line

The twist is that the law didn't win here. The phone did. Whoever controls the device ends up controlling how the rule gets enforced, and a company that once refused to hold your data was happy to let someone else hold it.

So here's the short version. A website had to prove its visitors were adults. It refused to collect IDs and faces, then returned once Apple offered to do the checking. The risk of holding your data didn't vanish. It just changed hands.


Whether you ever visit a site like this or not, the

Whether you ever visit a site like this or not, the same choice is coming for every app that asks who you are. Knowing who holds your proof is the first step to deciding what you're comfortable sharing. The full story's in the description if you want the deep dive.

Ready for forensic-grade facial comparison?

Full forensic reports with detailed similarity scoring. Results in seconds.

Run My First Search